Affiliate Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. This does not affect the price you pay.
A colander does one thing, and whether it does it depends entirely on one number that almost no manufacturer prints.
Two of the ten below publish a hole size. They read 0.5 inches and 3.5 millimetres.
That is a 3.6-fold difference, on two products sold under the same word to the same person. Half an inch drains a pot of rigatoni in a second and puts your orzo down the drain. Three and a half millimetres holds the orzo and takes noticeably longer with the rigatoni. Neither is wrong. But you cannot choose between them if nine listings out of ten will not tell you which one you are buying.
What you get instead is adjectives. “Tiny and closely spaced holes.” “Micro-perforations.” “Fine mesh.” One listing on this page — a $19 silicone one, not the $32 or the $50 — has a bullet point headed “HOLE SIZE NOTE — SUITS MEDIUM-TO-LARGE FOOD — NOT FOR FINE GRAINS OR RICE”, which is the most useful sentence in the entire category and reads like something written after too many returns.
Below: ten colanders from $9.99 to $49.99, four different formats, and the second thing nobody mentions — whether the base lifts your food out of the washing-up water it is draining into.
Our Quick Picks
Best OverallGulex 3-Quart Colander
The category’s number one at $13.99 — 304 steel, riveted handles, and holes small enough that spaghetti stays in.
Most PremiumOXO Good Grips 5-Quart
Three raised feet, non-slip elevated handles and a body that nests inside a mixing bowl — the best-executed colander here.
Best SetTiawudi 3-Pack Mesh Baskets
Three graduated mesh baskets that hold what a perforated colander loses — rice, quinoa, orzo and flour.
At a Glance
Ten Colanders Compared
Format first, because four different tools share this keyword — then capacity, then the hole size that eight of these ten decline to measure.
| # | Model | Type | Capacity | Hole Size | Base | Standout | Main Drawback | Check Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 |
 Gulex 3-Quart Colander |
Perforated bowl | 3 quarts | Not stated — “tiny and closely spaced” | Riveted handles, no feet | #1 in Colanders, #342 in Kitchen & Dining | Included Components field lists a lid it does not have | View on Amazon |
| 2 |
 OXO Good Grips 5-Quart |
Perforated bowl | 5 quarts | All-over perforation; size not stated | Three raised feet | Nests inside mixing bowls for storage | $31.95, more than twice the category leader | View on Amazon |
| 3 |
 Tiawudi 3-Pack Mesh Baskets |
Fine mesh basket | 5, 4 and 3 quarts | Fine mesh — holds rice and quinoa | Wide rim and resting base | Three sizes, and mesh fine enough for grains | Mesh dents more easily than a perforated bowl | View on Amazon |
| 4 |
 EXCELSTEEL 5-Quart |
Perforated bowl | 5 quarts | 0.5 in, published | Self-draining base | One of only two listings here that measure the holes | Half-inch holes lose anything small | View on Amazon |
| 5 |
 BeFare Metal Set of 3 |
Mesh basket, powder coated | Three sizes | 3.5 mm, published | Solid wide base | The finest published aperture here, at a third of the EXCELSTEEL | $49.99, the most expensive product on this page | View on Amazon |
| 6 |
 U.S. Kitchen Supply Over-Sink 6 Qt |
Over-sink, collapsible | 6 quarts | Fine mesh — holds rice | Rests on the sink rim | Handles extend from 14 to 21 inches | Rectangular basket wastes some sink space | View on Amazon |
| 7 |
 Comfify Silicone Over-Sink 6 Qt |
Silicone, over-sink, folds flat | 6 quarts | Stated in prose: not for fine grains or rice | Bridges the sink rim | The only listing here that warns you what it cannot hold | Heat rated to only 176°F | View on Amazon |
| 8 |
 PriorityChef Colander |
Perforated bowl | 3 quarts | Described as micro-perforations; not measured | Raised base | Holes small enough for rice, per the listing | Model number field reads “3 Qrt” | View on Amazon |
| 9 |
 Kteniy 3-Quart Colander |
Perforated bowl | 3 quarts | Fully perforated; size not stated | Footed design | 304 steel and a footed base for $11.99 | A bullet describes three sizes; only one ships | View on Amazon |
| 10 |
 Glad Collapsible 2L |
Plastic and TPR, folds flat | 2 litres — smallest here | Not stated | Rubber grip ring | Folds to 1.3 inches, the flattest here | Only 2 litres, and top-rack only | View on Amazon |
Specifications, prices and ratings are taken from each manufacturer’s Amazon listing as displayed on 21 August 2026 and may change. The Hole Size column reproduces each listing’s own words: only the EXCELSTEEL (0.5 inches) and the BeFare (3.5 millimetres) publish a measurement, and the rest are recorded as described rather than converted into a figure. Two listing anomalies are reported as published rather than corrected: the Gulex lists a lid among its Included Components and no lid ships with it, and the Kteniy single 3-quart colander carries a bullet reading “THREE SIZES 3-Quart / 4-Quart / 5-Quart”, which belongs to a three-piece set. Listing copy is shared across brands in this category: the Kteniy material bullet is near-verbatim with the Tiawudi set’s, and both appear in near-identical form on other colanders in the same node under further brand names. Amazon’s Colanders & Food Strainers node also contains cheesecloth, nut-milk and filter bags, fat separators, tofu presses, spider skimmers and fine-mesh tea sieves, all filtered out before verification. Four further colanders were verified live but excluded for brand duplication, format redundancy or missing price data.
Scroll the table sideways to see every column
How We Chose These Colanders
We researched current listings, compared manufacturer specifications and documentation, and examined recurring patterns in customer feedback. We did not carry out hands-on testing, and nothing below is presented as measured performance data.
- Whether the hole size is published — the specification that decides what you keep and what you lose
- Whether the base lifts the food clear — a flat base sits in whatever is already in the sink
- Format — perforated bowl, mesh basket, over-sink and collapsible are four different tools
- Capacity against a real pot of pasta — three quarts is tighter than it sounds
- How the handles are attached — riveted survives; spot-welded is where these fail
- How it stores — a rigid colander nests with nothing and takes a whole shelf
The 10 Best Colanders, Reviewed
1. Gulex 3-Quart Colander — Best Overall
#342 in the whole of Kitchen & Dining and the top-ranked colander on Amazon, for $13.99. It is also, at seven ounces, the lightest metal colander in this roundup.
Key Specifications
| Type | Fully perforated bowl |
|---|---|
| Capacity | 3 quarts |
| Steel | 18/10, 304 stainless |
| Diameter | 8.8 in; 11 in including handles |
| Height | 3.9 in |
| Weight | 7.04 ounces |
| Handles | Riveted |
| Dishwasher | Safe |
| Rank | #1 in Colanders, #342 in Kitchen & Dining |
| Rating | 4.4 out of 5 stars |
| Best For | The everyday colander, and the one most people buy |
Why We Recommend It
Riveted handles are the detail worth paying for and the reason this outlasts cheaper versions. A colander handle takes the entire weight of a pot of pasta plus boiling water, applied as a jerk when you tip the pan. Spot-welded handles are the standard failure point in this category — the weld shears and the handle peels off the rim. Rivets pass that load through the bowl wall instead of a weld bead.
On hole size, the listing gives you a phrase rather than a number: “tiny and closely spaced holes”, with the specific promise that spaghetti will not fall through. That is more than most of this page manages, and it is still not a measurement. Spaghetti is about 2 mm thick, so the claim implies holes under that — fine for pasta and vegetables, and no guidance at all on rice or quinoa.
304 grade 18/10 is the good stuff — 18% chromium, 10% nickel, which is what makes it genuinely rust-proof rather than rust-resistant. It matters here because a colander lives wet.
There are no feet, and at 3.9 inches deep with a flat base this sits directly in whatever it is draining into. In a sink with standing water, the food sits in that water. Several colanders further down solve this with a raised base or three feet, and it is the single biggest functional difference between them.
The Included Components field says “Lid”. There is no lid. It is a specification-field error rather than a missing part, but it is the kind of thing worth noticing before you order.
Pros
- #1 in Colanders and #342 in all of Kitchen & Dining
- Riveted handles rather than spot welds
- 18/10 304 stainless — properly rust-proof
- Holes fine enough that spaghetti stays in
- Seven ounces, the lightest metal colander here
- $13.99
Cons
- No hole measurement published, only a description
- No feet or raised base — it sits in the sink water
- Included Components field lists a lid that does not exist
- 3 quarts is small for a family pasta pot
- 4.4 stars, mid-table in this roundup
Best for: Most kitchens, most of the time — provided you drain into an empty sink.
2. OXO Good Grips 5-Quart — Most Premium
Thirty-two dollars for a colander, against $9.99 at the bottom of this page. It also carries the joint highest rating in the roundup at 4.8.
Key Specifications
| Type | Fully perforated bowl |
|---|---|
| Capacity | 5 quarts |
| Base | Three raised feet |
| Handles | Elevated, non-slip |
| Weight | 16 ounces |
| Storage | Nests inside mixing bowls |
| Dishwasher | Safe |
| Rank | #4 in Colanders, #1,507 in Kitchen & Dining |
| Rating | 4.8 out of 5 stars — joint highest here |
| Price | $31.95 |
| Best For | Anyone who drains into a sink that is not always empty |
Why We Recommend It
The three raised feet are the reason to buy it, and they solve a problem most people have stopped noticing. Drain pasta into a sink that has a couple of inches of washing-up water in it and a flat-bottomed colander simply sits in that water — the bottom layer of pasta soaks in it while the top drains. Feet lift the perforated base clear, so everything drains and nothing re-wets. It is a small design decision that changes the outcome every single time.
Elevated non-slip handles are the other one. A colander is lifted with wet hands, often while it is hot and heavy, and OXO’s handles stand proud of the rim so your fingers get underneath rather than pinching the edge. This is what the brand is for.
All-over perforation rather than a perforated base. Holes up the sides as well as underneath mean water leaves in every direction as you shake it, which is quicker and less prone to the trapped pocket you get in a bowl with a solid wall.
It nests inside a mixing bowl, which sounds like a storage note and is actually a technique: sit it in a bowl, rinse rice or greens in standing water, then lift the colander straight out and the grit stays behind in the bowl. Very few colanders are shaped to do this.
No hole measurement, as with almost everything here. At $31.95 that is the one disappointment — this is the listing that could most easily afford to state it.
Pros
- Joint highest rating here at 4.8 stars
- Three raised feet keep food out of standing sink water
- Elevated non-slip handles designed for wet hands
- All-over perforation drains in every direction
- Nests in a mixing bowl for rinsing and storage
- 5 quarts — enough for a family pasta pot
Cons
- $31.95, more than twice the category leader
- No hole size published, at the highest price here
- 16 ounces, heaviest single colander in this roundup
- Ranked #4 while cheaper colanders rank above it
- Nothing here a $14 colander with feet could not do
Best for: Anyone who has ever fished pasta out of dirty sink water.
3. Tiawudi 3-Pack Mesh Baskets — Best Set
Three sizes for $16.99, joint highest rated on this page, and #2 in the category. More to the point, these are mesh rather than perforated, which changes what they can do.
Key Specifications
| Type | Fine mesh basket |
|---|---|
| Set | 5 qt (11 in), 4 qt (9.5 in), 3 qt (8.5 in) |
| Steel | 18/8 stainless, BPA, lead and cadmium free |
| Frame | Wide mirror-finished rim, top and bottom |
| Base | Resting base on each |
| Weight | 1.4 lb for the set |
| Dishwasher | Safe |
| Rank | #2 in Colanders, #712 in Kitchen & Dining |
| Rating | 4.8 out of 5 stars — joint highest here |
| Best For | Rice, quinoa, orzo, and anyone tired of losing grains |
Why We Recommend It
Mesh is the answer to the question this whole page is about. A perforated colander is a sheet of steel with holes punched in it, and the holes have to be big enough to punch and small enough to hold food — in practice 2 to 5 mm. A woven mesh basket has apertures well under a millimetre. That is the difference between rinsing quinoa successfully and washing half of it down the drain.
Three sizes is not padding here. The 3-quart handles a cup of rice, the 5-quart takes a full pot of pasta, and they nest. Given that fine mesh drains more slowly than big holes, having a large one for pasta matters more than it would with a perforated bowl.
The wide rim on both top and bottom is the structural point. Loose mesh distorts under a heavy wet load and never comes back; a firm wire framework around the rim and a resting base at the bottom hold the shape. Combined with the firm wire down the outer sides, this is what separates a mesh basket that lasts from one that goes out of round in a month.
They rest in the pot as well as the sink, so you can lift blanched vegetables straight out of boiling water without pouring anything.
Mesh is more fragile than a perforated bowl. It dents where a solid bowl would shrug, and a dented mesh basket is hard to clean and impossible to straighten. Do not stack heavy things on them.
Note the shared copy. The sentence about being made of “first class Stainless Steel” that is “BPA free, Lead and Cadmium free” and “rust free and will never affect the taste of your food” appears almost word for word on the Kteniy colander further down this page, under a different brand.
Pros
- Joint highest rating here at 4.8 stars
- Fine mesh holds rice, quinoa, orzo and flour
- Three graduated sizes that nest, for $16.99
- Wide rim and resting base keep the shape
- 18/8 stainless, dishwasher safe
- Rest in the pot to lift out blanched vegetables
Cons
- Mesh drains more slowly than punched holes
- Dents permanently, unlike a solid bowl
- Harder to scrub clean than a perforated colander
- No aperture measurement published
- Shares near-verbatim listing copy with another brand here
Best for: Rice, grains and small pasta — and as a second colander alongside a perforated one.
4. EXCELSTEEL 5-Quart — States Its Hole Size
Fourteen ninety-nine, 4.5 stars, five quarts. And a Mesh Opening Size field that reads 0.5 inches, which almost nothing else in this category publishes.
Key Specifications
| Type | Fully perforated bowl |
|---|---|
| Capacity | 5 quarts |
| Mesh opening | 0.5 inches — stated in the listing |
| Size | 14 x 11.5 x 5.25 in including handles |
| Weight | 8 ounces |
| Finish | Mirror polished |
| Base | Self-draining |
| Warranty | 1 year against manufacturing defects |
| Rank | #6 in Colanders, #1,791 in Kitchen & Dining |
| Rating | 4.5 out of 5 stars |
| Best For | Large pasta, potatoes and anything you cannot lose |
Why We Recommend It
Half an inch is 12.7 mm, and that is a big hole. It is excellent for what it is built for — a large volume of water leaves almost instantly, potatoes and rigatoni and broccoli drain in a second, and nothing clogs. It is also completely unsuitable for orzo, rice, quinoa, couscous, small berries or anything else under about a centimetre, all of which will go straight through into the sink.
That is not a criticism of the pan. It is the whole argument of this page. Every colander makes this trade, and this is the one product that lets you make it knowingly. The BeFare set further down publishes 3.5 mm — a third of the aperture — and the two are sold to the same buyer under the same word.
Eight ounces for a five-quart colander is very light, which is a mixed blessing: easy to handle, and thin enough that the rim will flex if you grip it hard when loaded.
The self-draining base lifts it clear, so unlike the Gulex it will not sit in standing water.
It is the only colander here with a stated warranty, at one year against manufacturing defects — not long, but more than the nothing everything else offers.
Pros
- Publishes an actual hole size, which almost nothing here does
- Drains a large pot of pasta almost instantly
- Five quarts for $14.99
- Self-draining raised base
- Mirror polished and dishwasher safe
- One-year warranty, the only one in this roundup
Cons
- Half-inch holes lose rice, orzo, quinoa and small berries
- Thin at 8 ounces — the rim flexes under load
- 14 inches across including handles; awkward in a small sink
- No handle detail published — welded or riveted is unstated
- Warranty is only one year
Best for: Large pasta shapes, potatoes and vegetables — and nothing small.
5. BeFare Metal Set of 3 — Finest Published Mesh
Fifty dollars, which is the most expensive thing on this page by eighteen dollars. It is also one of only two listings here that publishes an aperture, and at 3.5 mm it sits at the opposite end of the range from the EXCELSTEEL’s half inch.
Key Specifications
| Type | Mesh basket, powder-coated metal |
|---|---|
| Set | Three sizes, largest 12.5 x 11 x 7 in |
| Mesh opening | 3.5 millimetres — stated in the listing |
| Base | Solid wide base |
| Finish | Cream powder coat |
| Weight | 1.63 kg for the set |
| Rank | #21 in Colanders, #5,000 in Kitchen & Dining |
| Rating | 4.7 out of 5 stars |
| Price | $49.99 |
| Best For | Anyone who wants the hole size known and the kitchen to look good |
Why We Recommend It
3.5 mm against 12.7 mm is a 3.6-fold difference, and both products are called colanders and sold to the same person. At 3.5 mm you keep orzo, most rice and small pasta; you lose quinoa and couscous, which need mesh proper. It is a sensible general-purpose compromise and it is the number you would actually want on every listing in this category.
The wide solid base is doing two things. It stands stably on a worktop when loaded, which a round-bottomed basket does not, and it keeps the perforated sides clear of any standing water in the sink. On a set that will spend time on the counter holding washed produce, that stability matters.
Powder-coated metal rather than bare stainless is a genuine trade. It looks considerably better — this is the only colander here anyone would leave out on display — and a powder coat can chip, and once chipped the metal underneath is exposed to a permanently wet environment. Treat it more gently than you would treat steel.
1.63 kg for three makes these the heaviest set on this page, and they do not nest as compactly as the mesh baskets above.
#21 in the category at 4.7 stars — a good rating and a low rank, which is what a $49.99 price does in a category whose leader costs $13.99.
Pros
- Publishes a 3.5 mm aperture — a genuinely useful number
- Fine enough for orzo, small pasta and most rice
- Wide solid base stands stably when loaded
- Three sizes
- 4.7 stars
- The only colander here that looks good left out
Cons
- $49.99 — the most expensive product in this roundup
- Powder coat can chip, and then the metal is exposed
- 1.63 kg, the heaviest set here
- Does not nest as compactly as bare mesh baskets
- #21 in the category, well behind cheaper colanders
Best for: Anyone who wants a known aperture, a stable base and something presentable.
6. U.S. Kitchen Supply Over-Sink 6 Qt — Best Over-Sink
Six quarts, the largest capacity in this roundup, on handles that extend from 14 to 21 inches to span the sink.
Key Specifications
| Type | Over-sink basket, collapsible |
|---|---|
| Capacity | 6 quarts — largest here |
| Basket | 13 x 9 in rectangular |
| Handles | Expandable rubber, 14 to 21 in |
| Mesh | Fine — holds rice and small ingredients |
| Base | Resting feet |
| Weight | 1.4 pounds |
| Dishwasher | Safe |
| Rank | #3 in Colanders, #787 in Kitchen & Dining |
| Rating | 4.6 out of 5 stars |
| Best For | Draining a heavy pot without a second pair of hands |
Why We Recommend It
An over-sink colander solves a different problem from a normal one. With a colander in the sink you are holding a heavy pot of boiling water in two hands and aiming; with an over-sink basket the colander is already supported, so you have both hands on the pot and nothing to line up. For anyone with weak wrists, or draining a full stockpot, that is the entire reason this format exists.
The extending handles are what make it fit. Sinks vary enormously and a fixed-width frame either falls in or overhangs; 14 to 21 inches covers nearly everything. Measure across your sink rim before ordering — that is the one dimension that decides whether this works.
Fine mesh rather than punched holes, so this is one of the few large-capacity items here that will hold rice. Combined with six quarts, it is the most versatile single piece on this page.
It collapses into the sink basin rather than folding flat, which is a more limited kind of collapsible than the silicone ones further down — it saves you nothing in a drawer.
A 13 by 9 inch rectangular basket in a round-cornered sink leaves dead space, and the basket occupies most of the sink while it is in use. If you wash up as you cook, this gets in the way.
Pros
- Six quarts, the largest capacity here
- Both hands stay on the pot — no aiming
- Handles extend 14 to 21 in to fit most sinks
- Fine mesh holds rice and small ingredients
- #3 in Colanders at 4.6 stars
- Dishwasher safe
Cons
- Blocks most of the sink while in use
- Measure your sink rim first — fit is not guaranteed
- Collapses into the basin, not flat for a drawer
- Rectangular basket wastes space in a curved sink
- Fine mesh drains more slowly than punched holes
Best for: Heavy stockpots, weak wrists, and anyone who has scalded a hand aiming a pan.
7. Comfify Silicone Over-Sink 6 Qt — Most Honest Listing
This listing does something no other product on this page does, and it is worth singling out.
It has a bullet point headed “HOLE SIZE NOTE — SUITS MEDIUM-TO-LARGE FOOD — NOT FOR FINE GRAINS OR RICE”, and it appears to have been written in response to buyer feedback.
Key Specifications
| Type | Silicone over-sink, folds flat |
|---|---|
| Capacity | 6 quarts |
| Handles | Extendable, spans up to 25 in |
| Folded | 1.4 inches flat |
| Heat | Rated to 176°F |
| Holes | Stated as suiting medium-to-large food, not fine grains or rice |
| Weight | 1.4 pounds |
| Rank | #27 in Colanders, #7,238 in Kitchen & Dining |
| Rating | 4.7 out of 5 stars |
| Price | $18.99 |
| Best For | Small kitchens, and anyone who values being told the truth |
Why We Recommend It
That is the single most useful sentence in this entire category, and it is on a $19 silicone colander rather than the $32 OXO or the $50 BeFare. It is a manufacturer choosing to tell you a limitation up front and lose the sale rather than take a return, which is rare enough to be worth rewarding.
Folding to 1.4 inches is the real feature. A rigid 6-quart colander is a genuinely awkward object to store — it does not stack, it does not nest with anything, and it occupies a shelf. This one goes in a drawer. In a small kitchen that can be the deciding factor over any question of drainage.
Extendable to 25 inches is wider than the U.S. Kitchen Supply’s 21, so it spans larger and double sinks that the metal version will not.
The 176°F heat rating is the thing to watch. Boiling water is 212°F. The listing describes draining boiling pasta straight from the pot, and rates the silicone to 176 — those two statements sit uneasily together. In practice water cools as it falls and silicone is tolerant, but if you routinely pour a rolling boil straight in, the metal alternatives have no such number attached.
Silicone is quieter, kinder to sinks and impossible to dent, and it will discolour and hold odours over time in a way steel does not.
Pros
- The only listing here that states what will fall through
- Folds to 1.4 in and stores in a drawer
- Spans up to 25 in — fits double sinks
- Six quarts, joint largest here
- 4.7 stars
- Will not dent, and is quiet in a steel sink
Cons
- Rated to 176°F while boiling water is 212°F
- Not for rice, quinoa or fine grains — as it says
- Silicone stains and holds odours over time
- #27 in the category
- Flexes more than metal under a heavy load
Best for: Small kitchens, double sinks, and anyone who rewards an honest listing.
8. PriorityChef Colander — Best Small Perforation
Thirteen dollars for a perforated colander that explicitly claims to drain rice — which, at these hole sizes, is the claim that matters.
Key Specifications
| Type | Perforated bowl, micro-perforations |
|---|---|
| Capacity | 3 quarts |
| Size | 12.25 x 8.85 x 4.4 in including handles |
| Base | Raised, keeps food clear of water |
| Weight | 0.22 kg |
| Claim | Drains rice without ingredients slipping through |
| Dishwasher | Safe |
| Rank | #23 in Colanders, #5,246 in Kitchen & Dining |
| Rating | 4.6 out of 5 stars |
| Price | $12.99 |
| Best For | Rice and small pasta, without moving to a mesh basket |
Why We Recommend It
“Micro-perforations” is a description, not a measurement, and this listing does not give a number either. But it does make a specific functional promise — draining rice “without any ingredients slipping through” — and a stated promise you can hold a seller to is worth more than the vague “tiny and closely spaced” language elsewhere on this page. Rice grains are roughly 2 mm wide, so the implied aperture is around a millimetre.
The raised base is the same idea as the OXO’s feet, at 40% of the price. It lifts the perforated bottom clear of whatever is in the sink, which is the difference between drained pasta and re-wetted pasta.
Micro-perforation has a real cost: speed. Small holes drain more slowly than large ones, and a full pot of pasta into a 3-quart micro-perforated bowl will back up briefly before it clears. That is the trade for not losing anything, and it is the correct trade for most people.
Three quarts is small. For a 500 g pack of pasta this is at its limit, and you will be draining in two goes or watching it brim.
The model number field reads “3 Qrt”, which is a capacity, not a model number — a small sign of a listing assembled quickly.
Pros
- Claims explicitly to drain rice without losing it
- Raised base keeps food out of sink water
- $12.99, among the cheapest metal colanders here
- 4.6 stars
- Won’t bend or rust, per the listing
- Dishwasher safe
Cons
- No aperture measurement, only “micro-perforations”
- Small holes drain noticeably more slowly
- 3 quarts is tight for a full pack of pasta
- Model number field contains a capacity
- Shares listing phrasing with other brands in this category
Best for: Rice, couscous and small pasta, without buying a mesh basket.
9. Kteniy 3-Quart Colander — Best Budget Metal
Eleven ninety-nine and #5 in the category. It is the cheapest colander here made from 304 stainless with a footed base, which is a decent combination at the price.
Key Specifications
| Type | Fully perforated bowl |
|---|---|
| Capacity | 3 quarts |
| Steel | 304 stainless, lead and cadmium free |
| Size | 11 x 9 x 3 in |
| Base | Footed |
| Weight | 0.22 kg |
| Edges | Rounded, no rough perforation edges |
| Dishwasher | Safe |
| Rank | #5 in Colanders, #1,598 in Kitchen & Dining |
| Rating | 4.4 out of 5 stars |
| Best For | A cheap, footed metal colander that does the basics |
Why We Recommend It
The rounded perforation edges are worth a mention because the alternative is genuinely unpleasant. Punching holes in thin steel leaves a burr on one side, and a cheaply finished colander has a sharp lip around every hole — it catches on cloths, snags delicate food, and will nick a finger during washing up. This listing specifically states that the interior and exterior are smooth and the edges rolled over. That is the corner most $12 colanders cut.
The footed design does what the OXO’s feet do, keeping the base clear of standing water, for a third of the price.
Then read the second bullet. It says “THREE SIZES — 3-Quart / 4-Quart / 5-Quart sizes for all your cooking, straining and preparation needs”. This is a single 3-quart colander. That text belongs to a three-piece set — the same 5/4/3-quart set format sold by other brands in this category — and has been pasted onto a single-unit listing. The material bullet is likewise near-identical to the Tiawudi set’s higher up this page.
None of that makes the colander bad, and 4.4 stars across #5 in the category suggests buyers are content. It does mean you should read the title and the dimensions, and ignore the bullets.
Pros
- $11.99 for 304 stainless with a footed base
- #5 in Colanders
- Rounded perforation edges — no burrs or sharp lips
- Footed, so it stays out of sink water
- Dishwasher safe
- Light at 0.22 kg
Cons
- A bullet describes a three-size set; one colander ships
- Listing copy is near-identical to another brand here
- No hole size stated
- 3 quarts is small for family pasta
- 4.4 stars, joint lowest metal rating in this roundup
Best for: A cheap second colander, bought on the title rather than the bullets.
10. Glad Collapsible 2L — Best Collapsible
Ten dollars, four ounces, and it folds down to an inch and a third. For a certain kind of kitchen that combination beats every other consideration on this page.
Key Specifications
| Type | Collapsible plastic with TPR |
|---|---|
| Capacity | 2 litres — roughly 2 quarts |
| Folded height | 1.3 inches |
| Size | 11.5 x 9.3 x 3.4 in in use |
| Base | Rubber grip ring, anti-skid |
| Weight | 4 ounces — lightest here |
| Dishwasher | Top rack only |
| Rank | #24 in Colanders, #6,349 in Kitchen & Dining |
| Rating | 4.3 out of 5 stars |
| Price | $9.99 |
| Best For | Small kitchens, caravans, student flats and second homes |
Why We Recommend It
Storage is the real problem with colanders and almost nobody frames it that way. A rigid colander is a hollow hemisphere: it does not stack with anything, it does not nest with anything except another colander, and it takes a full shelf to hold a couple of quarts of air. This folds flat into a drawer.
The rubber grip ring on the base is the detail that makes collapsibles usable. Folding designs are light, and a light colander skitters across a wet sink when you pour into it. A rubber ring underneath holds it still.
Two litres is genuinely small — roughly two quarts, against six for the over-sink baskets. This is a colander for a portion or two of pasta, a punnet of berries, a bag of salad. It is not the colander for Sunday lunch.
Top-rack dishwasher only, which is the standard restriction on plastic and TPR. The lower rack is nearer the heating element and will warp it.
4.3 stars is the lowest rating in this roundup, and collapsible colanders earn that honestly: the folding action loosens over time, and a folding colander that has lost its rigidity is a worse tool than a rigid one that cost the same. This is a format with a shorter life than steel, bought for a reason other than longevity.
Pros
- Folds to 1.3 in and lives in a drawer
- $9.99, the cheapest colander here
- Four ounces — the lightest thing on this page
- Rubber grip ring stops it skidding
- Genuinely useful in caravans, boats and small flats
- Top-rack dishwasher safe
Cons
- Two litres is the smallest capacity in this roundup
- 4.3 stars, the lowest rating here
- Folding action loosens with age
- Top rack of the dishwasher only
- No hole size stated
- Plastic stains from tomato and turmeric
Best for: Small kitchens and small quantities — not a family pasta colander.
The Hole Size Nobody Publishes
Quoted exactly as each listing gives it. Only two are measurements.
| Colander | What the listing says about hole size | What it will hold |
|---|---|---|
| EXCELSTEEL 5 Qt | 0.5 inches — measured | Rigatoni, potatoes, broccoli |
| BeFare Set of 3 | 3.5 millimetres — measured | Orzo, small pasta, most rice |
| Comfify Over-Sink | “Not for fine grains or rice” — stated in prose | Pasta, vegetables, berries |
| PriorityChef | “Micro-perforations”; claims to drain rice | Rice, per the listing |
| Gulex 3 Qt | “Tiny and closely spaced”; spaghetti won’t fall through | Pasta and vegetables |
| Tiawudi Set of 3 | “Fine mesh” | Quinoa, flour, rice |
| U.S. Kitchen Supply | “Fine mesh”; prevents rice escaping | Rice and small ingredients |
| OXO 5 Qt | Nothing — “all-over perforated” | Unknown |
| Kteniy 3 Qt | Nothing — “fully-perforated” | Unknown |
| Glad Collapsible | Nothing | Unknown |
Three of these ten give you something you can act on: two numbers and one plain-English warning. Four more make a functional claim you could hold them to — spaghetti will not fall through, rice will not escape. Three say nothing whatsoever, and one of those is the most expensive single colander on this page. If you cook rice, quinoa, couscous or orzo, that silence is the difference between a tool and a disappointment, and it is worth choosing from the top half of this table.
Four Different Tools Share This Keyword
These are not variations. They solve different problems.
| Format | In this roundup | How it works | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Perforated bowl | Gulex, OXO, EXCELSTEEL, Kteniy, PriorityChef | Punched holes, drains fast | Pasta and vegetables |
| Fine mesh basket | Tiawudi, BeFare | Woven mesh, sub-millimetre | Rice, quinoa, flour, sifting |
| Over-sink | U.S. Kitchen Supply, Comfify | Bridges the rim on extending handles | Heavy pots, both hands free |
| Collapsible | Glad, Comfify | Folds flat for storage | Small kitchens, occasional use |
The perforated bowl is the default and it is the right default: it drains fastest, cleans most easily and survives longest. Mesh is the specialist — slower and more fragile, but it is the only thing that reliably holds grains, and if you rinse rice regularly you want one. Over-sink is not about drainage at all; it is about not holding a heavy pot of boiling water in two hands while aiming. And collapsible is bought for the cupboard rather than the sink, which is a perfectly good reason as long as you know that is the trade.
Best Alternatives
| Alternative | Why Consider It | Better For | Main Trade-Off |
|---|---|---|---|
| A clip-on pot strainer | Clips to the pan rim; nothing else to wash | Pasta, one pot, small kitchens | Fits some pans and not others |
| A pasta pot with a strainer lid | One vessel does everything | People who cook a lot of pasta | Useless for rinsing or washing produce |
| A spider skimmer | Lifts food out, leaves the water behind | Blanching and deep frying | Not a draining tool for volume |
| A fine-mesh sieve | Sub-millimetre; sifts as well as drains | Grains, stock, flour | Slow, small, and dents |
| A slotted spoon and patience | You already own one | One portion | Exactly as tedious as it sounds |
What Each Price Tier Actually Buys
$9.99 to $14.99 — Glad, Kteniy, PriorityChef, Gulex, EXCELSTEEL. The tier that contains the category’s number one, the only colander here with a published hole size, and three of the five footed bases. There is very little you can buy above this tier that changes what happens when you drain pasta.
$16.99 to $19.99 — Tiawudi, Comfify, U.S. Kitchen Supply. This is where format changes rather than quality. Three sizes of fine mesh, a silicone colander that folds into a drawer, or a six-quart basket that spans the sink. All three do something the tier below cannot.
$31.95 — OXO. The best-executed colander here: three feet, elevated handles, all-over perforation, nests in a mixing bowl. It is also the most expensive single colander in the roundup and it does not publish its hole size.
$49.99 — BeFare. Three powder-coated baskets with a published 3.5 mm aperture. You are paying for the finish and the fact that somebody measured the holes.
The pattern: price buys handles, feet and looks. It does not buy information — the two listings that tell you their hole size cost $14.99 and $49.99, and the $31.95 one tells you nothing.
How to Choose a Colander
Work Out the Hole Size Before You Buy
It decides what you keep. Half an inch drains a pot of pasta almost instantly and loses anything under a centimetre; 3.5 mm holds orzo and most rice and drains more slowly; woven mesh holds quinoa and flour and is slower still. Only two listings in this roundup publish a number, so use the functional claims instead — “spaghetti won’t fall through” implies under 2 mm, and “drains rice” implies about a millimetre. Where a listing says nothing at all, assume large holes, because a manufacturer with fine apertures usually says so.
Check Whether the Base Lifts the Food Clear
A flat-bottomed colander lowered into a sink that has water in it puts your food straight back in that water. Three raised feet, a self-draining pedestal or a rim that spans the sink all fix it, and the fix costs nothing to manufacture. This is the single most common everyday annoyance with a colander and it is almost never discussed in the listing — look at the product photograph from the side rather than the top, which is how you will actually spot it.
Buy for the Pot You Actually Use
Three quarts sounds ample and is not. A 500 g pack of dried pasta roughly triples in volume as it cooks, and it arrives all at once with a litre of water behind it — in a 3-quart colander that brims. Five to six quarts is the size for a household that cooks pasta for four; three quarts is a second colander for rinsing and small jobs. Measure against your largest pot rather than your average one, because the largest pot is when it matters.
Look at How the Handles Are Attached
This is where colanders fail, and it is not the bowl. A handle carries the whole weight of hot food plus water, applied as a sudden jerk when you tip a pan, and spot-welded handles shear off at the weld. Riveted handles pass that load through the bowl wall instead. Only one listing in this roundup states which it uses. Where it is unstated, the product photograph usually shows the rivet heads — and on an over-sink model, check the handles extend far enough for your sink before anything else.
Decide Whether You Are Buying for the Sink or the Cupboard
A rigid colander is a hollow bowl that nests with nothing and takes a whole shelf to store air. That is a real cost in a small kitchen, and it is why collapsible silicone and plastic models sell steadily despite draining less well and wearing out sooner. If storage is your binding constraint, buy collapsible and accept the trade knowingly. If it is not, buy steel — it drains faster, cleans better and will outlive several folding ones.
Match the Material to How You Will Treat It
304 or 18/8 stainless is rust-proof, dishwasher safe on any rack, and effectively permanent — it is the default for good reason. Silicone will not dent, is quiet in a steel sink and is kind to it, but it stains, holds odours, and one model here is rated to 176°F while boiling water is 212°F. Plastic is cheapest and lightest and belongs on the top rack of the dishwasher only. Powder-coated metal looks the best and chips, and a chip on a colander is bare metal in a permanently wet environment.
Common Colander Buying Mistakes
- Not checking the hole size. Eight of these ten will not tell you, and orzo and rice are the casualties.
- Buying a flat-bottomed colander. It sits in whatever is already in the sink.
- Buying three quarts for a family. A 500 g pack of pasta will brim it.
- Assuming a colander will rinse rice. Most will not; that is a mesh basket’s job.
- Ignoring how the handles are fixed. Spot welds shear under a pot of boiling water.
- Pouring a rolling boil into silicone rated to 176°F. Boiling water is 212°F.
- Putting a plastic colander on the bottom rack. It warps near the heating element.
- Buying an over-sink model without measuring the sink. Handle span is the only dimension that matters.
- Reading the bullets rather than the title. One listing here describes a three-piece set and ships one colander.
Which Colander Should You Buy?
Buy the Gulex 3-Quart if you want the one most people buy. #1 in the category, riveted handles, 304 steel, $13.99 — and drain into an empty sink, because it has no feet.
Buy the OXO 5-Quart if you want it right rather than cheap. Three raised feet, elevated handles, all-over perforation, and it nests in a mixing bowl.
Buy the Tiawudi set if you rinse rice, quinoa or grains. Fine mesh in three sizes, joint highest rated here, for $16.99.
Buy the EXCELSTEEL if you drain big pasta and want to know what you are getting. Half-inch holes, published, and a raised base.
Buy the BeFare set if you want a measured 3.5 mm aperture and something you can leave on the worktop.
Buy the U.S. Kitchen Supply over-sink if lifting a full stockpot is the hard part. Six quarts, fine mesh, handles from 14 to 21 inches.
Buy the Comfify if your kitchen is small or your sink is wide. Folds to 1.4 inches, spans 25, and tells you what it cannot hold.
Buy the PriorityChef if you want a cheap perforated bowl that claims to hold rice, with a raised base, for $12.99.
Buy the Kteniy if you want the cheapest footed 304 colander here — and read the title, not the bullets.
Buy the Glad if storage beats everything. Ten dollars, four ounces, folds to 1.3 inches.
Frequently Asked Questions
What size holes should a colander have?
It depends entirely on what you drain, which is why the silence in this category is so unhelpful. Around 4 to 5 mm is the general-purpose answer: fast enough to drain a pot of pasta quickly, small enough to hold spaghetti, penne and vegetables. Half an inch — the one large figure published in this roundup — drains rigatoni and potatoes almost instantly and loses orzo, rice and small berries. If you rinse grains regularly you do not want a perforated colander at all; you want a woven mesh basket, whose apertures are well under a millimetre.
Will a colander drain rice?
Most will not. A standard perforated colander has holes of roughly 4 to 5 mm and a grain of rice is about 2 mm wide, so a good deal of it goes through. Two products in this roundup address it directly: the fine-mesh baskets, which hold rice comfortably, and one micro-perforated bowl whose listing explicitly claims to drain rice without losing it. Everything else is a gamble. If you rinse rice, quinoa or couscous more than occasionally, buy a fine-mesh basket as a second item rather than hoping a colander will cope.
What is the difference between a colander and a strainer?
A colander is a bowl with punched holes, usually with feet or a pedestal, designed to sit in a sink and drain a large volume quickly. A strainer or sieve is a woven mesh in a frame, usually with a long handle, designed to catch much finer material — grains, flour, stock solids, tea. The names are used interchangeably on Amazon and this roundup contains both, which is precisely the problem: they look similar in a listing photograph and behave completely differently once your dinner is in one.
Are collapsible colanders any good?
They are good at exactly one thing, and it is not draining. A rigid colander is a hollow bowl that stacks with nothing and occupies a whole shelf; a collapsible one folds to under an inch and a half and lives in a drawer. For a small kitchen, a caravan, a boat or a student flat that can outweigh everything else. The costs are real though: the folding mechanism loosens with age, silicone stains and holds odours, plastic is top-rack only, and the lowest-rated product in this roundup is a collapsible one. Buy it for storage, knowingly.
Should a colander have feet?
Yes, and it is the most underrated feature in the category. Sinks are rarely empty — there is usually an inch or two of washing-up water sitting in the bottom — and a flat-based colander lowered into that puts the bottom layer of food straight back in it. Feet, a raised pedestal or an over-sink frame all lift the perforated surface clear so everything drains and nothing re-wets. Six of the ten products in this roundup have some form of raised base. Notably, the category’s number-one best seller does not.
Stainless steel, silicone or plastic?
Stainless for almost everyone. 304 or 18/8 grade is genuinely rust-proof rather than rust-resistant, survives any dishwasher rack, drains fast through punched holes and will last decades in a permanently wet environment. Silicone earns its place only for collapsibility — it is quiet, will not dent and is kind to a steel sink, but it stains, retains odours and one model here is heat-rated below boiling point. Plastic is the cheapest and lightest, warps on a dishwasher’s bottom rack, and stains from tomato and turmeric within months.
How do I stop pasta sticking after I drain it?
Drain it less thoroughly and dress it immediately. Pasta sticks because the surface starch dries and the strands bond, so the enemy is time sitting naked in a colander. Reserve a cup of the cooking water before you drain, tip the pasta straight into the sauce while still dripping, and use that starchy water to loosen it — the starch is what makes a sauce cling. Rinsing under cold water also stops the sticking and washes off the starch you want, so save it for pasta salad. Oiling drained pasta works and then stops sauce adhering.
Why do colander handles break?
Because of how they are attached, not what they are made of. The handle carries the entire weight of hot food plus water, and it gets that load as a sudden jerk when you tip a heavy pan in. Spot-welded handles concentrate all of it into two small weld beads, which fatigue and shear — usually while full. Riveted handles pass the load through the bowl wall over a wider area and very rarely fail. Only one listing in this roundup states which method it uses; on the rest, look for rivet heads in the product photograph.
Final Verdict
#1 in the category, riveted handles and 304 steel for $13.99.
Three raised feet, elevated handles, and it nests in a mixing bowl.
Fine mesh in three sizes — the only format here that reliably holds rice.
Colanders are about as simple as kitchen equipment gets, which makes it odder that the category is so uninformative. Ten products, four genuinely different formats, and the number that determines whether the thing works is published by two of them.
So read for it indirectly. A listing that promises spaghetti will not fall through is telling you it is under 2 mm. One that claims to drain rice is telling you it is around a millimetre. One that says nothing at all is usually telling you the holes are large, because fine apertures are a selling point and large ones are not.
Then look at the photograph from the side and check for feet, because a flat-based colander in a sink that is not empty puts your dinner back into the washing-up water — and the best seller in this entire category is the one product here without them.
Everything after that is format. A perforated bowl for pasta, a mesh basket if you rinse grains, an over-sink frame if lifting the pot is the hard part, and something that folds if the cupboard is the real constraint. Two of those cost under fifteen dollars.